Holey Cream in New York City

  Get the donut ice cream sandwich and don’t share it. It’s amazing. I need another one. Seriously just go for it!

  We found this place searching for best milkshakes near Hell's Kitchen...then we didn't get the milkshakes. The donut ice cream sandwiches are amazing. Fresh donut sliced in half and stacked with several scoops of whatever flavor you want (I had Irish Coffee made with Jameson's...More

  Great little neighborhood ice cream shop that has many flavors of ice cream and know for their doughnut filled ice cream sandwich. The coffee mud pie and Irish coffee flavors were excellent!